Nearly 2 Years Later, Who Won The Bo Horvat Trade?
Photo credit: Sportsnet
Nearly two years have passed since the Vancouver Canucks traded captain Bo Horvat to the New York Islanders. The blockbuster deal included a first-round pick (later flipped to acquire Filip Hronek), prospect Aatu Räty, and winger Anthony Beauvillier. This trade mirrored the franchise-altering move in 1998, when the Canucks traded Trevor Linden to the Islanders.
While the Linden trade clearly favored Vancouver-yielding key players like Todd Bertuzzi, Bryan McCabe, and draft assets that led to Daniel and Henrik Sedin-the Horvat trade's outcome remains less definitive.
Who Got the Better Player?
If trade success hinges on acquiring the best player, the Islanders likely win. Horvat remains a premier talent, scoring 33 goals last season and anchoring the Islanders' first line. Meanwhile, Beauvillier was traded in a cap dump, and Räty is still developing.
If trade success hinges on acquiring the best player, the Islanders likely win. Horvat remains a premier talent, scoring 33 goals last season and anchoring the Islanders' first line. Meanwhile, Beauvillier was traded in a cap dump, and Räty is still developing.
Filip Hronek, though technically not part of the trade return, has been a standout for Vancouver. Partnered with Quinn Hughes, Hronek has solidified the Canucks' top defensive pairing, contributing significantly to their playoff run. It could go either way but Horvat is more proven.
Replacing Horvat: A Work in Progress
The Canucks have struggled to fill Horvat's void, particularly on the power play, where his absence has been noticeable. Attempts to shore up the 2nd line center position, including the short-lived acquisition of Elias Lindholm, haven't fully replicated Horvat's contributions.
The Canucks have struggled to fill Horvat's void, particularly on the power play, where his absence has been noticeable. Attempts to shore up the 2nd line center position, including the short-lived acquisition of Elias Lindholm, haven't fully replicated Horvat's contributions.
Team Success Tells Another Story
Despite Horvat's departure, Vancouver has thrived as a team, winning the Pacific Division and advancing to the second round of the playoffs in 2024. In contrast, the Islanders have faced early playoff exits, suggesting Vancouver's team-oriented improvements have outweighed the loss of their star.
Despite Horvat's departure, Vancouver has thrived as a team, winning the Pacific Division and advancing to the second round of the playoffs in 2024. In contrast, the Islanders have faced early playoff exits, suggesting Vancouver's team-oriented improvements have outweighed the loss of their star.
The Räty Factor
Aatu Räty remains a wildcard. At 22, his potential as a reliable third-line center could tip the trade in Vancouver's favor long-term. His work ethic and development are promising, though his NHL spot isn't yet secure.
Aatu Räty remains a wildcard. At 22, his potential as a reliable third-line center could tip the trade in Vancouver's favor long-term. His work ethic and development are promising, though his NHL spot isn't yet secure.
Ultimately, the trade appears to be a win-win for both franchises, but the Canucks' broader team success might give them a slight edge.
| POLL | ||
NOVEMBRE 15 | 174 ANSWERS Nearly 2 Years Later, Who Won The Bo Horvat Trade? Who do you think will end up being the winner of the Bo Horvat trade? | ||
| Vancouver Canucks | 91 | 52.3 % |
| New York Islanders | 37 | 21.3 % |
| Tie | 46 | 26.4 % |
| List of polls | ||
MUST READ
